EatCheapEatWell
  • Home
  • SHOP
  • Life/Budget/Household Stuff
  • Food and Meal Blog
  • About
  • Home
  • SHOP
  • Life/Budget/Household Stuff
  • Food and Meal Blog
  • About

The Problem With the 50-30-20 Budget Rule

9/12/2016

 
Why the 50-30-20 Budget Rule Is a Bad Idea
​This often used budgetary rule of thumb states you should try to keep your necessary expenditures to 50% of your total income, your discretionary expenditures to 30%, and the remaining 20% of your income should go towards savings.

While this approach is definitely not a bad starting point for money management, it's far too broad and general, and even terrible advice for many financial situations.
​
Let me explain what I mean.
Let's say, for example, that you happen to be among the lucky few who have a high salary, say ​of $150,000 or more. So let's assume for simplicity's sake that your take home pay is around $100,000. 

That does not mean that your housing, food, and other necessities should be half that, or $50-$60,000 per year or more. 

That would be absurd, in fact. 

By contrast, if you’re in the lower salary ranges, some of your necessary expenses might push the total past the 50% mark.  For example, w
hen we started out, I was the sole breadwinner, and my take-home was a mere $800 per month. Our rent alone was $350, and we had utilities,food, transportation, and college tuition as essentials to pay. They came to well over half of my earnings. 

In today's dollars, if you make $35,000, your take home pay would be in the ballpark of $28,500. It's perfectly feasible that your rent and grocery bill, combined with your transport costs, utility bills and medical deductibles and co-pays would be more than $14,000, or 50% of your income. Heck, rent alone can easily cost that in some parts of the country. 

Of course, it's to be hoped that this is a temporary situation that will ease because your earnings will rise. But it's actually not an uncommon scenario at all, particularly when young people are starting out. Or for older people facing job loss and low-salary replacement jobs in these economic times. 

When it does occur, the necessities consume a higher percentage of the budget. Which leaves less income available for discretionary expenses. 

So your budget might conceivably look more like 55-25-20 or even 60-20-20 during these times. ​

Notice, though, that the savings percentage does not decrease. That's because you should always cut the budget in the area of discretionary spending before you cut your savings. ​
But my biggest issue with the 50-30-20 rule is that I think the savings percentage in  is just too conservative for those in higher income brackets.

​After all, someone bringing home $100,000 should be able to live comfortably on a lot less than $80,000 and save more than $20,000. 

A more prudent approach than sticking to a 20% rule is to increase the savings percentage of your budget as much as possible as income goes up, and to keep the other costs to conservative levels, so their share of your earnings actually goes down.

That way, you’d ensure that you are living well beneath your means and are well situated to to cope with any unexpected financial crises that may befall you. 

It's savings, after all, that help us weather those unpleasant occurrences. They sure did that for us. You can read about the budget curve balls we've experienced in my blog about the topic.  
Beyond that, there's the issue of achieving financial freedom some day. That's the ultimate goal of any budget plan, after all, and I think the 50-30-20 plan falls short in this regard.

Saving 20% of your income is a great starting point. But if your expenditures are always rising to meet your income whenever it goes up, that invariably puts you on a treadmill to perpetual financial dependence. 

You have a far greater chance of actually achieving some level of financial security if you apply only a modest amount of a raise to lifestyle changes, and putting most of it towards savings, 
​
In that scenario, you would not necessarily scale up to a more expensive house or apartment, or a luxury car. And you also wouldn't suddenly start spending more on food or utility bills or clothing just because you could afford to do so. 

No, those costs would remain constant, so, with your higher income, your budget numbers might look more like 45-25-30, for example. And it would be an absolutely painless savings increase since you would not have to tighten your belt in any way. 

So, here's my advice. Use the 50-30-20 rule mostly as a very loose guideline to get you started on a budget. But always be looking to increase the savings portion of the rule whenever you can.  

That's the ticket to financial health and eventual freedom. 
​
Here’s an article on the matter that goes into greater detail. 
Picture

Comments are closed.
    Follow Me
    Picture
    PictureMy "boys" and me

    The Author

    Hi, I'm Nancy Maje Gillis, and I hope to help you find ways to live more cheaply and mindfully to  help you get through this uncertain COVID-19 time  so that you have less stress and more money in your pocket.

    Archives

    November 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015

    Categories

    All
    -12 Kitchen Sanity Savers
    -20 No-Effort Ways To Save Big At The Grocery Store
    -2 Travel Hacks To Save Money
    -4 Basic Grocery Store Hints
    -4 Ways To Find More Savings In Your Budget
    -5 Basic Money-Saving Steps To Take Before Hitting The Grocery Store
    -5 Things To Consider In College Aid Offers
    -7 Simple Shopping Strategies That Save
    -8 Easy Ways Anyone Can Save At The Grocery Store
    -8 Tips For Budget Travel
    -9 Helpful DIY Hints
    -9 Steps To Finding A College
    -A College Degree For Less Time And Money
    -Adjusting To Life On A Budget
    -Benefits Of Eating Like You're Poor
    -Budget Basics
    -Budget Busting Bottled Water
    -Budget Eating For Good Health
    -Budgets And Peer Pressure
    -Budget Worksheet
    -Christmas Tree Watering Hack
    -Cleaning Products And The Environment
    -College Money Matters
    -Cooking In Quantity For Savings
    -Cooking Sprays - 4 Reasons To Avoid Them
    -Cooking Your Way To Health And Savings
    -Costco Savings Myth
    -Cut Utility Bills With This Easy Hack
    -Deli Department Savings
    -Dirty Dishes
    -DIY Yourself To Financial Independence
    -Eat Real Cheese And Save
    -Finding Ways To Pay For Your Next Vacation
    -Food Budget And Portion Size
    -Food Savings For Small Households
    -Frugality Pays Off
    -Gardening To Save Money
    -Healthcare And Our Budget
    -Helps For Getting Yourself Organized
    -Hot Weather Energy And Money Savings
    -Household Matters
    -How A Frugal Lifestyle Saved Us From Ruin
    -How To Build A Nest Egg
    -How To Choose A College Major
    -How To Save On Your Housing Budget
    -How To Stay Within A Food Budget
    -In Praise Of Peanut Butter
    -It's Not How Much You Earn That Matters
    -Keurig Coffee Pod Alternatives
    -Kitchen Gadgets Worth Owning
    -Laundry Savings
    -Lessons Learned From Mom And Dad
    Lessons Learned From Mom And Dad
    -Living Within Our Means Is Not Enough
    -Local Produce Bargains
    -Magic Sinks
    -Marketing Traps In Recipes
    -Microwave Hacks That Save Time And Money
    -Mom's Multivitamin
    -Myths That Contribute To Food Waste
    -On Gratitude And Humility
    -Organic Food As A Necessity
    -Parenting And Budgets
    -Pet Money Saving Tip
    -Pets And Your Budget
    -Pressure Cooker Introduction
    -Put Gas Money Back In Your Pocket
    -Romance On A Budget
    -Safe Food Handling
    -Save $668 Painlessly
    -Save On Your Wintertime Heating Bill
    -Saving BIG On Toilet Paper
    -Saving Money Is About Spending Choices
    -Saving Money On Wire Transfers
    -Savings And Opportunity
    -Saving Your Way To Financial Freedom
    -Savvy Grocery Shopping
    -Scams That Cost You Money
    -Snack Savings
    -Soap Savings
    -Starbucks Hacks
    -Successful Strategy For Meeting Personal Goals
    -Sugar In Our Food
    -Take-Out Food Alternative
    -Tax Savings
    -Tax Scams And How To Avoid Them
    -The 50-30-20 Budget Rule
    -The Real Cost Of Take-Out
    -Time To Rethink Those Holiday Traditions?
    -Tips For Sticking To A Holiday Gift Budget
    -Tips To Save On Fruits And Vegetables
    -Valentines' Day On A Budget
    -When We Have Too Much Stuff
    -YouTube Can Improve Your Bottom Line

    RSS Feed


Home

SHOP                              Life/Budget/Household Stuff               

              Food and Meal Blog             About                      

Copyright © Nancy Maje Gillis 2015-2025